Trakt Lists: The New UI Needs Key Improvements

Hey Trakt fam! We've gotta talk about the new Trakt Lists page. While we appreciate the continuous efforts to enhance our beloved platform, there are some pretty significant changes to the lists functionality that are, quite frankly, hurting the user experience for many of us. We're talking about fundamental features that were essential to how we organized and interacted with our media. The original discussion really highlighted these pain points, and as loyal users, we believe it's super important to bring these concerns to the forefront. It’s not just about aesthetics; it’s about functionality, control, and the sheer joy of curation that Trakt lists used to offer. We’re deep divers into movies and TV shows, and our lists are a reflection of our tastes, our plans, and our watch history. Losing the intuitive controls and the rich information density we once enjoyed feels like a step backward, making it harder for us to manage our cinematic journeys effectively. Think about all the effort we put into crafting these lists – from 'Must-Watch Indie Gems' to 'Future Binge-Watching Plans' – they're more than just collections; they're our personal databases. When the tools we use to manage these databases become less efficient or less informative, it genuinely impacts our overall satisfaction. So, let’s dive into the specifics, guys, and explore why these new changes are causing a bit of a stir and what we hope to see return or improve in the future. We're all in this together, wanting the best for Trakt and its incredible community.

The Vanishing Act of Customization: Where Did Our List Options Go?

First up, let's tackle the missing customization options for Trakt lists. For many of us, the ability to tailor our lists precisely to our needs was a cornerstone of the Trakt experience. We're talking about the freedom to arrange lists in a custom order, tweak settings, and generally make them feel truly ours. Losing these customization options isn't just a minor inconvenience; it's a significant downgrade that really impacts how smoothly we can navigate and manage our massive collections of shows and movies. Imagine having a meticulously organized bookshelf, and then suddenly all your books are just tossed in haphazardly—that’s kind of how it feels when the custom order in which lists are shown vanishes. Previously, we could set up our lists so our most important ones, like 'Up Next' or 'Current Binge,' were always at the top, easily accessible. Now, with this crucial feature missing, finding specific lists can become a frustrating scavenger hunt, adding unnecessary clicks and wasted time to our daily Trakt routine. This isn't just about personal preference; it’s about efficiency and user-friendliness. Our interaction with Trakt lists often begins with wanting to quickly access or update a particular list, and when that quick access is removed, the entire flow of using the platform gets disrupted. We invested time into setting up our ideal list displays, and seeing that effort undermined is genuinely disheartening. It’s those little touches of personalization that transform a good platform into a great one, making users feel truly at home. So, for the Trakt list customization faithful, bringing back the ability to set a custom list order is paramount. It’s not just a 'nice-to-have'; it's a 'must-have' for a seamless and enjoyable experience. The original discussion highlighted that these options were really hurting our experience, and that sentiment is widespread. When core organizational tools are removed, the platform loses some of its magic, turning what should be a straightforward task into a chore. Let's get that granular control back, guys, because it truly makes a world of difference for how we engage with our content on Trakt.

The Dimming Dilemma: Why Watched Items Are Hiding in Plain Sight

Next, let’s talk about one of the most baffling changes: the inconsistent dimming of watched items in list views. Seriously, what's going on here? The idea behind dimming might be to visually distinguish watched content, but the current implementation is causing more confusion than clarity. The user provided screenshots perfectly illustrate this problem, showing how certain items are dimmed while others, under similar conditions, are not. This lack of uniformity creates a visually jarring and inconsistent presentation that makes navigating our lists a real headache. But here’s the kicker, and this is where it gets really weird: the system sometimes classifies unreleased items as “watched” and dims their posters. Guys, think about that for a second. An item that hasn't even come out yet is being treated as if we've already seen it. How can you watch something that isn't even available? This totally breaks the logic of what 'watched' means and renders the dimming feature utterly unhelpful for planning our future viewing. Imagine you're building a 'Future Movies to See' list, and half the posters are dimmed because the system thinks they're 'watched.' It defeats the entire purpose of a clean look of all items on a list, which is what most of us are after. We want a clear, unambiguous view of what's in our lists, whether it's something we've seen, something we're planning to see, or something yet to be released. This inconsistent presentation of items based on watch state creates a messy interface where you can't quickly scan and understand your list at a glance. It's especially problematic when you're using Trakt for discovery or for curating lists for others. A potential recommendation list, for example, would look confusing if unreleased items are dimmed or if the dimming logic is all over the place. We're not asking for a complete removal of the feature if it serves some users, but at the very least, it needs to be optional or have its logic drastically improved. The current state, as highlighted in the discussion, is far from ideal and genuinely hinders the visual clarity that makes a list so effective. We need to be able to trust what we see, and right now, the dimming feature is eroding that trust. Let's get this fixed so our Trakt watched items actually reflect reality and our lists maintain their visual integrity.

The “My Lists” Page: Where Did All My Lists Go?

Moving on to another head-scratcher: the new Trakt Lists page often doesn't show all of your lists at the same time. This is a huge step back in terms of usability and information density. Previously, on the old lists page, we had a comprehensive overview where every single one of our lists was immediately visible. Now, you often find yourself scrolling endlessly or clicking through pagination, even when there's clearly ample space on the screen. The original feedback rightly pointed out that